As a hunter, I don't think one can only have one pair of hunting boots.
I own several pairs of Cabelas boots.. everything from leather outfitter boots to camo nylon to Pac boots. Depending on the hunt and the conditions, I wear them all.
If it's dry, I wear lace-up boots in camo HD nylon boots (they're light weight & comfortable, allowing me to do a lot of walking.)
If it's raining or rained over night, I wear insulated irish setters rubber boots.
Boots have to fit properly because you'll probably be doing a lot of walking. if they don't fit, too heavy or not enough support, it will ruin your hunt and give you blisters.