Would have been nice to get some of those higher paying refinery jobs located inside the US borders. I have a feeling more than one person looking for work would love a refinery job and the added taxes they would have to pay.
An oil pipeline will leak. Not a if but it will leak. Comparing a oil pipeline leak to a blow out oil well is not an accurate comparison.
Shipping oil via rail will result in leaks also.
Oil is a world wide commodity. No matter where it is produced. The price is set by world demand. If the US market for crude oil or finished product exceeds the prices others are willing to pay. Than the oil goes to where the market demands it goes. Hence the reason for futures contracts on crude oil and other commodities. So if oil were produced from Western Nebraska and some moron in Germany was willing to pay $200 a barrel for the stuff....it isn't going to be sold for $100 and kept inside the US. All the producer gets is what they can sell it for and some jobs for the people willing to work. All the government gets is to collect various types of taxes.
That is why gasoline, NG , propane and other finished products are exported from the US.
We have refineries some other countries do not have any or do not have the refining capabilities for domestic consumption. Hence the reason we import a raw product (crude oil) finish it (gasoline) and send it off to Europe among other places. In that process we get American jobs and collect taxes.
If we, the US, finds itself needing more gasoline than we are capable of refining, we will be importing it from some place else, and paying more for it.
If we as a country do not desire to have a pipeline run down the middle of the US, for what ever reason. That is fine, but just remember. We also will not be collecting any money off of any of the oil that will be pumped through it nor any jobs at the refineries. To assume that we the US are the only market where crude oil from Canada can be finished is arrogant.
It is cheaper for Canada to send crude to Texas for finishing than to ship if off to someplace else. That is the only reason Canada wanted to ship the stuff to Texas.
My view, it is to bad that we could not find a way to ship the stuff to Texas. I prefer the control of the pipeline, taxes and jobs to be in American hands rather than somewhere else.
Once again it appears the US policy makers are going to bend to the will of those who are more concerned about possible environmental issues than solving real domestic issues. I also worry about environmental issues, but I care more about keeping the US GDP growing. Anytime someone would like to explain how we can create jobs while guarding the environment. Please speak up. (oh wait some have and they get ignored by Washington) We as a nation have the raw resources to do both, it just seems the policy makers drag their feet on these issues.