Hunter, you are absolutely right. I don't know how many times different people have told me, if you hunt with a commercial guide, "No matter what you hear about how "wild" the birds are, with all the hunters that descend on SD in the Fall, most of the birds you shoot will be preserve birds." The cost is nontrivial and only the topography has changed. That stands to reason; when gangs of 4-8 guys limit out or near limits each day of a weeklong trip, multiplied by hundreds/thousands of groups, there just aren't that many wild birds out there!! This last fall I started hunting at a preserve 160 miles west of home--flat land in Illinois--good cover, birds were fast runners/strong flyers and honestly, after shooting over 400 wild birds in the last 25 years I was hard put to tell the difference, and my dog got a hell of a lot more work. I heartily salute the guys who live in Iowa, SD, Nebraska etc. who have time to scout religiously, talk to cafe and retail business owners, search the hunting apps and atlases
and ID all the "hot" walk in areas, but living in northern Indiana and with gas at near $3.40/gallon, for me that just does not make sense. It just isn't cost-effective at all. I'll still take a trip or two west each year, but certainly not because it makes economic sense--because it doesn't.