The anti Magnum person

onpoint

Active member
What's up with the person's that are "Anti Magnum" anything, be it 10, 12, 16, 20 or 28?

It's like the anti Christ to some.

If you tell them you shoot a 10ga for waterfowl. They just about loose their mind. Then there's the 12ga "Roman Candle' the ultimate sin 3.5" 12ga.

The 3" 20ga

The 1.25oz 16ga

1oz 28ga

God for bid...Fioochi had a 3" 28ga listed at one time. My God, they flipped. Why would they do this. They are going to wreck this great upland gun by introducing such a thing.

It just stymies me. I have even seen that folks would label anybody using any of the above as a poor hunter if you need these.

I have shot 1.25oz 16ga loads for years. They were the standard go to load back in the hay day of waterfowling or chasing wild roosters late in the fall.

I have had a 10ga auto loader for as many years as they have been made. My Remington has to be 25 or more years old. Killed 100's if not 1,000's of geese with it. Before that, it was several Ithaca Mag-10's. Same with the 3.5" 12ga. I have put a lot of ducks and geese in the freezer with one and have the pictures to prove it.

My dad started me off with a 3" 410 and I moved to the 3" 20ga until I was old enough to drive about. Then I was on to bigger and better but have had a long love affair with the 3" 1.25oz 20ga in #6 or #7-1/2.

Why is it, they only let you use 1-1/8 oz loads at the trap and skeet ranges when using a 12ga? Why does the range master make anybody caught shooting a hunting load, "Stop Shooting" and gets them a box of target loads? It's simply too much of a advantage and hens the rule of no more then 1-1/8oz load is to be used.

The pattern board is only one dimensional. It does not show shot string. A longer shot string gives the possibility of more chance of catching the bird in your pattern, then if the shot string is shorter.

Let the fur fly...Problem is, too many go on this anti magnum thing and go with a lighter load because they read this somewhere. Not that they actually even patterned any load. I bet far more then 90% have never even patterned their gun EVER! You can ask why are you shooting this light load? Oh, I read in blah, blah magazine that this load patterns better or better yet. I read it on the net on a talk forum. Well, that settles it, it was on the net...it's gospel.

Which would you prefer, I throw two rocks at you from 20ft away or I throw I throw a whole hand full of rocks at you from 20ft away. There's a pretty good chance I will miss you with two rocks but I bet I connect with the whole hand full of rocks.

You ever see a turkey pattern board after it's been shot with 2-1/4oz of #6's? You can't stuff much more shot into a 12ga hull. Yet it is the choice by far of most turkey hunters.

I know all about the square load thing. I have shot plenty of birds with a light load and had that bird run off wounded, where a heavier load left them stone dead. Nothing I hate more then loosing a bird. It makes me sick, I would go as far as wrecking my day on some occasions.

I am a magnum man, always have and always will be. The time is too short that we have to be out in the fields and woods and taking what amounts to be a trap load with to harvest the beloved table fair one can't buy in the store just doesn't cut it for me. It would be great if we hunted in a perfect world where birds always jump 15-20 yards from us or ducks commit and drop in our face but face facts..that's just not the way it always is. Nothing cranks me up more then taking someone who shoots these type of loads. Then have them not shoot at birds repeatedly over and over with the excuse it was too far. When you know you could have dumped any one of those birds with your gun and ammo combo. A wasted day with little to show for it. Then you feeling obligated to send half your limit home with them. As I said, too little time there is to waste those very limited days accomplishing little more then enjoying the weather.

Onpoint
 
For me its not that I'm "anti magnum" (I love my 22mag) its just that after reading, and patterning, I have found square loads to be superior in my guns. I'll take shots out to 40yds on roosters and drop them dead with 1oz loads, beyond that range is a crap shoot with any gauge/ load combo. I've dropped birds dead after others just dropped a leg with their magic whammo load. The science is that with a shorter shot string of a square load a higher percentage of the shot will intercept a target when the shooter does his job.

A couple years ago I was talking with a guy and his son and he was saying he couldn't find any 3" 20ga for his son so I gave him 3 boxes of 3" remm pheasant loads and even set him and his son up as a blocker on our first push of the day. If I was anti I wouldve just thrown them away.

Sure I pass on shots, its the thing to do sometimes but I also drop some marvelous shots on occassion. Everyone gets cripples, no matter what you shoot but hopefully we have good dogs to track them for us. So shoot what works for you and we'll both be happy and our birds will be the same amount of dead at the end of the day.:cheers:
 
I am not anti-anything. I really don't like shooting the mag's, I don't like steel shot either! I grew up with lead, despite what anybody say's it's far superior to steel or the "nice shot" type shells. Because steel is the order of the day, high capacity and extra-ordinary FPS are the rule. I shot the old Super X 3" mags. as a kid, out of a model 12, with lead in the stock. Even weighted down it was miserable. We shot with accuracy 2 3/4" high base shells, lead, and it was exceptable for harvesting anything with feathers at a reasonable range. Now magnum's make sense. I still don't like to shot them, I am a better shooter with out them. But I absolutely hate wounding, I watched my compatriots at the club wound ducks, geese, almost on every flight, had them gimp over the water and crash in a field 1/4 away. Unrecoverable. I wouldn't have shot, but as a kid, I am sure I did both of the above. Reality now means magnums. If you watch the TV shows, with waterfowling, the goose hunting is an anti hunting show. Winged birds flopping around, being photographed, even with mags these "experts" rarely kill anything. I personally am in favor of mags, restore the 8 gauge with steel, eliminate the plug, any thing at all to get clean kills, at normal ranges. As for me, if you can find it, I will use a 20-28ga, double over about 5-6#'s and hunt over really good pointers, shooting imp cyl. and or nothing at all, shooting quail or ruffed grouse with 1 ounce of lead shot, and enjoy myself. Leave the mag's at home, for waterfowl, or turkeys, coyotes, deer, and riot control, I'll have to dust them occasionally. I am wary about taking the field with a guy who "needs" a 3" mag #4 's full choke, to shoot pheasants over pointing dogs. I have been there for that, and see testament here. So I would say, I am not "down" on mags., but I am less enthusiastically about actually using one! But the deal breaker for me is the crippling with less than killing power at hunting ranges, I believe the mags help with that.
 
I'll even nominate the best gun if you use mags. I say the camoflaged Benelli Nova or Super Nova, 12ga. and 3 1/2" chamber can shoot anything, anywhere, bar none. If it was you in the wilderness, need reliability, hunting in the rain, the snow, need food to survive, it would my choice. With tubes and a range of ammo from target loads to goose killers, you could never go back, except for walnut, grace, and fine blueing.
 
Yep a lot of guys wet their pants at the mention of 3.5 loads especially online where the same info is recycled over and over. There is no substitute for power when you need it.
great post! :cheers:
 
The fact of the matter is roosters are no tougher now than they were when our grandfathers or great grandfathers hunted them and a wild rooster from one state is no tougher than one from another. I'm glad no one ever told the birds I hunt that it takes more than an ounce of shot to cleanly kill them. My guns (20 and 28ga) have the same chokes cyl/ Ic in them all season long and are fed the same diet of ammo all season long and I believe that makes me a more consistent shot. I know my own and my guns limits and respect them. If that means passing on more shots as the season progresses so be it, I hate losing a bird as much as anyone. If someone can't find a bird in the field I will always gladly bring the dogs around and help find it no matter how long it takes if asked, no matter what gauge or shell combo another chooses.:thumbsup:
 
I my self am not against any, I shoot mainly the 1,500 FPS fed premium's as said several times. That load in a 2 3/4", oz and a 1/4, just performs like a mag. I just have no need for anything more when using them I guess is all. I used to shoot 3 1/2" lightfield slugs in my beneli, now that is a flippin magnum right there boy. Hang on, and don't recommend trying any in anything but a beneli,LOL. They will dot your forehead, or knock u flat out if you don't hang on to your scope gun. But they will drop deer at 200 yards. Pretty impressive for a slug. 3,700 ft lbs of muzzle energy. Goose hunting I shot the big magnum loads all the time. I just don't hunt much other then upland birds any more. To me Fed created me my perfect fit in that PF load and it just flat out works for me.
 
Last edited:
While I am essentially an anti, I advised in an earlier post that I will use 3"20 ga. late in the season (pheasant) and my Dad killed hundreds of honkers with his Superposed and 3"#4 in the lead days. I used #4 12 ga 3" and certainly appreciate the 3.5 in steel for geese. I have not shot the 16 mag load. I beleive Federal is the only one making it and they were $35 a box last fall at Cabela's. If Iam hunting large ducks or geese, I'll just stick to the 12 3 or 3.5.
See the Wounded Warrior hunt photos 9 birds all shot with standard 16s in the late season. One bird ran and Zeeb shot that at a distance I would not have (in fact did not, I hollered "Coming your way") The rest were pointed and dead on retrieve.
I do think 1&5/8 12s are overkill on pheasants and encourage some long range hope and prayer shots that leave some birds crippled and in the field. At my age , I just do not need to do it.
Having grown uo in SD I appreciated your comments on going from the .410 up as I did exactly the same. Wonderfull years.
 
Nevermind it's not worth arguing I know what I can do with heavier loads.

And I know what I can do with 1oz.:cheers:

There are a lot of things I don't like or see the need for so I just abstain, nothing against anyone who does use them but I'm still entitled to have an opinion on a subject.

Every one please see my thread "Thought for the day" in the lounge, it will lighten the mood a bit.
 
Last edited:
There are a lot of things I don't like or see the need for so I just abstain, nothing against anyone who does use them but I'm still entitled to have an opinion on a subject.

Well said Quail.

This debate could go on forever and know one is going to win over anyone else.
We all have our pet loads and pet chokes to go with them. I'm with you quail, I'll just abstain..;)
 
It's whatever You have confidence in.
Federal Premiums 12 ga 2 3/4 heavy loads in 4 shot full choke.
Federal premium Black Cloud # 3 for ducks.
I recall only 1 pheasant running after shot in 012, the pup quickly took care of that.:thumbsup:
3 Giant Canadians killed dead with the same Black Cloud:)
That's all the geese I killed this year, that's all I wanted to clean and eat.:eek:
 
Back
Top