I was with them for 5 years, up until December -- I think it's a pretty good club. They've got a ton of land to hunt and strip pits to fish. You reserve a 'farm' on their online system and go hunt it. Members are required to fill out a 'game report' after they hunt listing everything they saw, shot or caught before they can reserve another farm. It's on the honor system, so a member who's got a honey hole and doesn't want to share it can easily send in a crummy report. I came to think the game reports were more trouble than they were worth. I spent a ton of time trying to glean information from them, but the layout and limitations of the reports make them far less useful than they could be. HSP are sticklers for rules, and there are lots of them. More than they need, honestly. No real complaints, I just wanted to look at other options so I talked to the guys at Mid-America Hunting.
MAHA is similar to HSP in most ways -- lots of ground, online system. But no game reports. You reserve a 'map' which is a portion of a county, and can have several properties on it. Lots of the maps have several hundred or even thousands of acres to hunt. It's nice to have options. (With HSP, you got your one farm and hoped it was good when you got there). The guys at MAHA are real friendly, helpful and come across as straight shooters. They seem to be knowledgeable about their properties, and work to find good ones that they keep for a long time. I like the guys and the way they run the business -- that's why I switched.
I'd check them both out. PM me if you'd like.