Did you ever end up with an o/u? If not I also vote for the 686 ultralight, if you are going to stick with a 12. I have both the 28” tubed barrels & 24” sk & sk. 5.9 lb with the tubes, but I generally shoot the short ones. If a 20, I would try an skb in 20. I am not sure what the new ones are like but the Ithaca/skbs had 25” barrels about 5.4 lbs. “magic wands”. I sold mine, but kept the ss with the English stock. The only problem with the Skb is if I shoot 3” the trigger guard hurts my 2nd finger on recoil. I only shoot short shells in the first barrel & hardly ever needed the 2nd!I've been getting the urge to get an O/U field gun which would be strictly for pheasant hunting. I picked up a browning 725 feather the other day and it felt really nice. I'm a lefty so if the gun is italian I'd have to get left hand wood on it. Browning field stocks seem neutral to me. Gauge doesn't matter, the only requirement is that it is a good gun for wiley roosters that often run, don't play by the rules, and flush on the edge of range. Thanks for any reccomendations.
Not a bad turkey gun either! Light, simple and effective!Did you ever end up with an o/u? If not I also vote for the 686 ultralight, if you are going to stick with a 12. I have both the 28” tubed barrels & 24” sk & sk. 5.9 lb with the tubes, but I generally shoot the short ones. If a 20, I would try an skb in 20. I am not sure what the new ones are like but the Ithaca/skbs had 25” barrels about 5.4 lbs. “magic wands”. I sold mine, but kept the ss with the English stock. The only problem with the Skb is if I shoot 3” the trigger guard hurts my 2nd finger on recoil. I only shoot short shells in the first barrel & hardly ever needed the 2nd!
I realize this is off topic, but I wouldn't want to use a lightweight shotgun for turkeys, solely because of magnum shells and recoil. I tried using my Monty once for turkey loads and that was awful. It kicked like a mule. IMO you're better of going with a heavier shotgun for turkeys, one that helps reduce the recoil from using a magnum turkey load.Not a bad turkey gun either! Light