An opinion from 2 years ago, was it valid??

Posted 10-7-2013 by Noplclkneb (Noplclkneb was banned shortly after this post) This post really got Uguide worked up :)


At the good wild bird commercial pheasant pay to play farms, you are paying the farmer to plant pheasant habitat, and farm for pheasants. To farm in this manner costs the farmer money, to pay for this cost he charges hunters a fee.

Its not a trespass fee, but a fee to pay for leaving in crops, not cutting and bailing grass/hay. The fee hopefully covers his extra costs plus some profit. The other great part about all the pheasant cover that is maintained on a good pay to play outfit, is that later in the season all the bonus surrounding pheasants flock to the good cover and away from the for profit only farmers moonscape land.

I paid to hunt wild birds the past two years near Winner. The place I went to did an outstanding job of farming for pheasants. Excellent habitat left for the birds and the habitat is set up to hunt. Plus the guys running it are excellent guides also. It was a great time and I would do it again.......as long as I am going to get my bang for my buck.

Here is where so many people seem to disagree with me. I'm not going to pay $300 + per day to see twice as many birds as I would see in Nebraska. I get it that some of you have zero birds in your state and just want to see a wild pheasant. That is fine, and more power to you, its suppose to be a free country, and who am I to tell you what to do.

Here is what I think is going to happen this year and in the future IF corn and hay prices stay high:
The pay to play farms that focus on great habitat for the birds are always going to have birds. The first two or three weeks will be good, but they are not going to get the influx of the bonus farm for profit neighbor's birds that keep coming to their great habitat later in the season because......there aren't any birds anymore on the neighbors moonscape land.

In Nebraska where I live no one farms for pheasants. The farmers here farm every square inch of land they can. But there are a few places around my place that are not farmable, a nice wetland, and some old abandoned farm places. They have birds, but for 10 miles in each direction there is not 1 pheasant, because there is no cover, none.

This is what I see happening in South Dakota also. Yes there are always going to be birds in South Dakota, but without the bonus neighbor birds coming in later in the season, it's going to kill the wild commercial hunting operations, other than the first couple weekends which will still be very productive.
Now am I saying don't hunt South Dakota? Hell no, South Dakota will always be the top pheasant hunting destination in the world because there is no center pivot irrigation, and the land is not as productive as Iowa, Nebraska, and Kansas, thus it is not worth as much and it is feasible to leave some land out of production for pheasant habitat. Will the pay to play farms have pheasants, hell yes! But in my opinion it will not be anything like it has been the past 10 years due to moonscape farmer next door to the pay to play places.
This can all change for the better if corn prices fall, and something replaces the CRP of yesterday.
I will most definitely hunt South Dakota again in the future, pay to play.....I don't know? Hunt public ground....probably not. Hunt with friends/family on private ground for a nice dinner out and a couple good bottles of whisky....sign me up!
 
Was it valid? I guess most of what he said was. Grain prices are no where near as high as they were a few years ago. That could change some of his assumptions. As for killing off the commercial hunting operations, I think he was quite pessimistic on that.

Curious as to why you felt the need to bring this up??
 
Was it valid? I guess most of what he said was. Grain prices are no where near as high as they were a few years ago. That could change some of his assumptions. As for killing off the commercial hunting operations, I think he was quite pessimistic on that.

Curious as to why you felt the need to bring this up??

Same member - new acct ? :p
 
the pay to play places will still get an influx of birds as the season wears on...they don't take delivery of all of their purchased birds at once.
 
the pay to play places will still get an influx of birds as the season wears on...they don't take delivery of all of their purchased birds at once.

What percentage of places that do it as a business release birds, in your opinion?
 
What percentage of places that do it as a business release birds, in your opinion?

Hunting camps with a preserve license and are required to release a minimum number of birds and probably release more than required to have enough birds for their clients. I imagine some hunting operations that are not preserves release some birds but I personally don't know of any. Do you release any Dennis?
 
All. How else can you constantly go out and kill the number of rosters they kill every day. With out the birds being pushed off or just killing all the roster and then just see hens
 
in a poor year, i can see how some guys might supplement a bit to protect their future business...wouldn't blame them if they did.....a guy needs clients every year to maintain.
 
All. How else can you constantly go out and kill the number of rosters they kill every day. With out the birds being pushed off or just killing all the roster and then just see hens

pretty sure the wild pheasant guys rest their ground several days each week.
 
All. How else can you constantly go out and kill the number of rosters they kill every day. With out the birds being pushed off or just killing all the roster and then just see hens

You are oh so wrong. I know several family farm type hunting operations that are not preserves. They have thousands of acres and manage their land for the pheasants. They leave adequate habitat and unharvested food sources. They are very careful of the number of birds they harvest over the season. They have enough fields that they probably only hunt the same field once or twice a week. The birds on these operations are all wild. There may be operations that supplement their birds numbers with some released birds but from my experience and living in SD for almost 40 years the percentage is very small. Now preserves that are allowed to hunt pheasants from Sept. 1st through March 31st it's a different story.
 
Hunting camps with a preserve license and are required to release a minimum number of birds and probably release more than required to have enough birds for their clients. I imagine some hunting operations that are not preserves release some birds but I personally don't know of any. Do you release any Dennis?

George, the only birds that I have released were Huns. I released some of them for a few years hoping they might get established again, that did not work. I have never released pheasants here. All my customers tell they can shoot pen raised birds at home. I would have to find new clients if I did. So not all hunting businesses do. When I was with Uguide, Chris was very clear that I should not release birds so I assume that is still the case with him.
 
You are oh so wrong. I know several family farm type hunting operations that are not preserves. They have thousands of acres and manage their land for the pheasants. They leave adequate habitat and unharvested food sources. They are very careful of the number of birds they harvest over the season. They have enough fields that they probably only hunt the same field once or twice a week. The birds on these operations are all wild. There may be operations that supplement their birds numbers with some released birds but from my experience and living in SD for almost 40 years the percentage is very small. Now preserves that are allowed to hunt pheasants from Sept. 1st through March 31st it's a different story.

You are right zeb, but what do we know. I personally know of three farmers in SD that farm for pheasants. They have large spreads of huntable acres. After the frst two weeks they rest the ground more than they hunt it. I can go to any of the three in december of a decent year and see hundreds if not thousands of birds. I know these guys very well and they do not buy birds, they don't have to. Sure if you are hunting a place that has six or seven hundred acres it will get shot out
 
You are oh so wrong. I know several family farm type hunting operations that are not preserves. They have thousands of acres and manage their land for the pheasants. They leave adequate habitat and unharvested food sources. They are very careful of the number of birds they harvest over the season. They have enough fields that they probably only hunt the same field once or twice a week. The birds on these operations are all wild. There may be operations that supplement their birds numbers with some released birds but from my experience and living in SD for almost 40 years the percentage is very small. Now preserves that are allowed to hunt pheasants from Sept. 1st through March 31st it's a different story.

I will agree with you. For the couple of family farm hunting operations I have friends running, they are 100% wild birds. Very good planning between the farming and hunting operations keeps the birds on their land in big numbers.
 
The family farm operation where we hunt intentionally keeps many standing corn fields well into the season. This does 2 things.
1. It gives the birds a safe haven to not get overshot the first few weeks of the season and 2. I'm a believer that most bordering farms birds make their way to this property as it's the only standing corn around.
Then by gradually harvesting the corn the farm is able to keep large amount of birds from opening week to the end of the season
 
The family farm operation where we hunt intentionally keeps many standing corn fields well into the season. This does 2 things.
1. It gives the birds a safe haven to not get overshot the first few weeks of the season and 2. I'm a believer that most bordering farms birds make their way to this property as it's the only standing corn around.
Then by gradually harvesting the corn the farm is able to keep large amount of birds from opening week to the end of the season

pretty damn clever..........:eek:
 
Back
Top