Not sure where you are from, but welcome to the forum. I am in Iowa and I often see rifles in the mixes, 270, 30-06 etc,...if you aren't in a state where you can deer hunt with the rifle cartridge, maybe pick one that you can hunt with. I guess I have pretty much anything I would want. Maybe a Tommy gun, the price to get it might be a bit higher than most, but I bet it would get the bidders fired-up! 1911s, maybe try a double stack or a 10mm. I love Springfield Armory XDm pistols. S&W or Ruger wheel guns; 357, 44 or 45. Maybe nicer shotguns, not the special editions or PF engraved, but ones to use. Maybe a 5.7X28 (Ruger 57). A few ARs are always good, maybe a heavy barreled varmint rig in 204 or just 223....or an AR10 in 243. Or ARs in the new deer legal calibers would likely be a big hit there. Crap, I should have made these suggestions to our PF directors! Hope you have a great banquet and can sometime get-in on a new land acquisition. A lot of downers on PF here, but they would sure hunt any ground PF can get and turn into public habitat.
M.C. Just out of curiosity, you are brand new, why did you not put in a location (even just a state) when you signed up? You aren't alone, many here don't and I am not sure what they are scared of....Hot Spotting your state??? Share your thoughts if you don't mind.