I appreciate all the thoughts. Here are a couple responses from me:
3car - if you ever see pasture land go for $300-$500 an acre please let me know. I would buy that in a heartbeat but I am extremely doubtful there is any property in the pheasant triangle that is going for that price today. The cheapest I have seen land is around that $1,500 an acre with an easement on it and a huge pond on the property. When I say big pond depends on the year but I would say pond is at least half of a quarter of the land. I don't mind having a pond on the property because I like the diversity but I hope it doesn't take up the whole property. If you have decent land then it's more like $2,000 an acre.
I agree, rather than buy a section with partners try to find a quarter by myself. Even at $2,000 an acre that's $320,000 which could be doable in a year or two when I can save a bigger down payment. Might be better to wait a couple years anyways because interest rates are around 8% for a 20 or 25 year loan and that was before the interest rate increase yesterday.
Somebody else said, you'll never get that money back. Depends on how you look at it. You could go to a really nice pheasant lodge (I know the whole debate on wild vs. pen raised) and spend $3,000 for a nice 3 day 4 night hunt and if I hunt for the next 40 years of my life that's $120,000. That is no where near the cost of buying a membership into a club or your own property around $250,000. I guess you just hope the land keeps appreciating in value and you have a place to take you kids.
I agree LLC needs to be rock solid. I used to work at a duck club in California. Back in the days the membership dues to buy in were close to 1/2 million and I've been told it has gone up even more along with an annual due of $25,000. That has gone up too of course. What hasn't? These guys had money though and flew in on private jets and went hunting for a couple days a year. I can only dream I win that 1 billion dollar lottery ticket but it's a 1 in 292 million chance to win so I never buy lottery tickets to begin with.
Lastly, land prices that are not in easements are out of control. I just saw a listing for 240 acres around Carthage, SD and it was for listed with
Midwest Land Group for 1.25 million. That's $5,200 an acre. I could never afford that. The sad thing is I don't really ever see land prices coming down drastically. I saw where the world population is approaching 8 billion people and they're not making more land.
Thanks for all the feed back and if any of you ever come across a nice wealthy laid back individual that will let me do all the hard physical labor and would buy 3/4 of the membership and be nice enough to let me in on the deal, let me know.