In my opinion, you can certainly make a bird dog at a preserve... Given that the birds are good flying birds. Like you said, it takes birds to make a bird dog, and I have started dogs in really tough times in terms of bird numbers and those dogs were a bit slower to develop. They still did, it just took longer. The pointer I have now, he was fortunate to start in good times and I sent him off to continue his education. It's paid off.Lot of good comments and thoughts on this thread. I hear all the talk about the way things used to be and can’t believe I didn’t know about bird hunting up until 6 years ago!!
Since that time, I’ve been blessed to start and work with 3 dogs from pup to where they are right now, raised three others that just didn’t have it IMO. All of their bird work took place on public land and I’d like to say I gave them all ample opportunity. Sure we do what we can in the back yard but I don’t have access to birds. 2 of them hit the jack pot right off the bat, got them in birds and made a dog quick. My GSP female that is not quite 2 just didn’t get into good positions last year (not the best year we ever had and what good opportunities you do have it’s hard to burn on pup training) made it a point to hit it hard and put her in birds this year, got creative and went outside the box going to different areas, I had my doubts of her over the summer, shame on me, my goodness her development has been unbelievable this fall/winter. She’ll never have another owner feed her.
The fun in it for me is the challenge to put them in the right position and it is AWESOME to watch their natural ability take over. Do have a question, I have always been timid to put my dogs on a preserve, I think there is something to be said for dogs learning how to get it done in a wild condition. Am I right in thinking that? I probably base it off my early days of working with rabbit dogs (beagles for 12 years), never had a pup make a dog that I trained in a starting pen. The good ones learned it all in the wild. The kicker for me is I know bird dogs are sooo much smarter than beagles, absolutely zero comparison. Can a fella make a bird dog at a preserve based on their smarts/ability or is there significant risk associated with that? I’ve wondered just haven’t pulled that trigger and tried it.
To each their own, I respect it all, I just love the sport and hearing all of the different perspectives. Thanks in advance for any comments that you guys might have.
That being said, if you can't find birds, I see no issue with a preserve, given that the birds fly well. (Well, for us pointy dog types) Certainly don't want your dog catching a bunch of crappy flying PR birds...
To me, the importance is the dog and the success for the dog. Dog doesn't care whether the bird was born in the wild or in a pen. I don't disparage those that don't either.
Wild birds if in abundance are the best obviously... But I'd rather the dog learn something rather then run in birdless habitat and learn nothing.