George, I agree - I've been buying "waterproof" leather boots since Dunham (CA) started the idea. Not sure when, but I believe these were the first to guarantee waterproof.
They were ok for a while, then leaked.
The boots I currently have now are leather and they started to leak. However, I discovered Sno-Seal and the stuff seems to work. I only use it on the toe area -so far, no leaks.
Have a great hunting season!