Ok first of all how were you patterning it?
I will explain. If you were shooting your patterns with the gun already pre-mounted and aiming to a specific spot that will only tell you how the gun itself is shooting or Point of impact as they call it. Big difference on how the gun actually fits you.
If you were mounting the gun and simultaneously firing at a fixed spot (no delay) this will show you how well the gun fits YOU. Please note, if your using this method. To get an accurate portrayal of how well the gun fits, you should shoot 5 shots one over the top of each other, focusing on a specific spot to get a good average. The possibility of a bad gun mount is inherent, thus the reason for 5 shots. You should also be just far enough away (20 yards) so that you can't see where your shot is hitting to avoid correcting yourself on subsequent shots. You will also want to use at least a modified choke, it just makes it easier to view.
This method will only work if your gun mounting skills are somewhat consistent, so you may want to hone your gun mounting a bit and try again at a later date to confirm.
As far as the spacers. If Benelli's spacers are anything like Beretta's they are marked with a number e.g 65,60,55 etc... the number's are in millimeters I believe. In layman's terms the larger the number the lower the stock, the smaller the number the higher the stock. More drop (higher number) causes the gun to shoot lower. The lower the number (less drop) causes the gun to shoot higher. If you are confident that your gun mounting is sound then you will want to put in a lower numbered spacer than the one that's in there.
Hope this helps