Like many topics here, each of us have our own experiences and information, one of the reasons that I enjoy this site so much.
I also really appreciate and respect the opinions and information on here that is passed back and forth. I know that I personally have utilized pieces of opinions and information since I joined.
I have had some of this/these discussions, especially over the last 4 years, with my vet and feel like I have a very good handle on my dog's health and what works. Some of those conversations might never had happened without the opinions and information shared on this site.
That is why I usually just put out there what I use and why, what works for this dog.....who is way different than my last dog that developed diabetes by the age of 4.....that was not fun to manage in a high drive waterfowl/upland lab.
So it is all relative to what works for us, and I'm going to give my dog every tactical advantage I can for his health.