Montana was a bust... South Dakota was fair

akersrob

Member
Well guys, after a lot of anticpation, and nerves, and exitement, I return to Virginia from Montana with good memories. The trip was great, I found Plentywood to have many friendly people, and met people I hope to stay in touch with I learned that pictures cannot capture this area of the world. The feeling you get when look across this big country is really undescribable.

We found very little birds, Saw 2 single sharptails, and nothuns, maybe abot 10 pheasants. The wind at times was very strong, first day had winds in the 50 mile an hour gust. Montana does a great job lining up the BMAs I feel. Some still had standing wheat, and some had some corn. The one place we did find birds was in some standing wheat.

My dog did grab a porcupine. This was dramatric for the dog, and me. She was trashing around so badly I had to pin her down and remove them on the spot, as she was breaking them off, and appeared to be doing more harm that good. knew I could not leave them until we got to the truck or to a vet. I was able to give her some pain meds, and rest the remainder of the day and she was back at it the next day.

I saw my first jack rabbit, mule deer, and porcupine. The size of the jackrabbit and the speed it had to me would compare to an antelope. That was surprising.

After 4 days, we decided to move to South Dakota, we knew nothing of the area, so we used OnX to find the most public ground. The good thing about the move it allowed us to get 10 hours closer to home. We hunted there 4 days, and was lucky enough to find birds each day. The winds here were also pretty strong here as well. Again lots of nice people in the area, and welcoming to us. One time my dog went on point when the winds were so strong, and the birds were like 60 yards away.

This was the first time the dogs and even I hunted wild birds. I still have a lot to learn. The first few days I allowed the dog to hunt to wide. They were bumping the birds out of range. The last few days tried to get them to hunt closer. I need to learn how to train this. I felt like I was constantly nagging the dog to stay close. Also my dog needs to be more steady, but to be honest there was times when her creeping helped me find the bird.

Overall a great hunt and experince.
 
Last edited:
Don’t feel bad about Plentywood, I’ve been going there since the mid nineties and I left after 3 days wasn’t the worst I’ve seen, 97 was and there was another year that sucked, sometime maybe 20 years ago. Just like you I ended up in SD without a clue. Like you I used onx to find a spot. We will see after a few days if this is a do over.
 
also, thank you guys for all the advice over the year. It was very helpful. Every bit of it was helpful.

The one thing to note was that someone gave advice to get Kinetic Hydro 30K to help keep the dogs hydrated. This worked almost to well. The funny thing is that my partner's dogs liked it so much they followed him around like the pied piper wanting more. After a few days he stopped carring it and started to carry just H20 to get them to hunt better.
 
You are not the only one that struggle near Plentywood, it was rough.. I’m glad I was warned and made a pivot to the south and found birds every day. Congrats for jumping into the deep end and taking a chance!
 
that is how I took your reply. Yep. I was ignorant about everything. I left with visions of birds behind every bush... :)
I haven't figured out South Dakota 100%, but the last trip I took last year late season, I did meet some really good dudes, and I think I'm going back. I like late season, because there aren't all these people playing grab ass all over the place.
 
South Dakota is kind of expensive, lodging is very expensive, it takes a few years to get it figured out, but the habitat is better than Montana. Don't get me wrong, Montana does have pheasant, and turkey, and elk, but I'm not going to put the pheasant hunting above South Dakota. No way.
 
This above ⬆️

Not "you are an infant.....".

It takes time in any craft to learn, grow, develop and adapt. Every one of us has been there and will be there again at some point.
Oh yeah, I have a feeling. I'm going to make a trip to South Dakota every year, because it's just a lot of fun. And I mean I'm not going to pay anybody but I will give away some birds and some beer.
 
You are not the only one that struggle near Plentywood, it was rough.. I’m glad I was warned and made a pivot to the south and found birds every day. Congrats for jumping into the deep end and taking a chance!
I know some guys that hunted Plentywood area last month and they had to drop further south to find birds.
 
Well guys, after a lot of anticpation, and nerves, and exitement, I return to Virginia from Montana with good memories. The trip was great, I found Plentywood to have many friendly people, and met people I hope to stay in touch with I learned that pictures cannot capture this area of the world. The feeling you get when look across this big country is really undescribable.

We found very little birds, Saw 2 single sharptails, and nothuns, maybe abot 10 pheasants. The wind at times was very strong, first day had winds in the 50 mile an hour gust. Montana does a great job lining up the BMAs I feel. Some still had standing wheat, and some had some corn. The one place we did find birds was in some standing wheat.

My dog did grab a porcupine. This was dramatric for the dog, and me. She was trashing around so badly I had to pin her down and remove them on the spot, as she was breaking them off, and appeared to be doing more harm that good. knew I could not leave them until we got to the truck or to a vet. I was able to give her some pain meds, and rest the remainder of the day and she was back at it the next day.

I saw my first jack rabbit, mule deer, and porcupine. The size of the jackrabbit and the speed it had to me would compare to an antelope. That was surprising.

After 4 days, we decided to move to South Dakota, we knew nothing of the area, so we used OnX to find the most public ground. The good thing about the move it allowed us to get 10 hours closer to home. We hunted there 4 days, and was lucky enough to find birds each day. The winds here were also pretty strong here as well. Again lots of nice people in the area, and welcoming to us. One time my dog went on point when the winds were so strong, and the birds were like 60 yards away.

This was the first time the dogs and even I hunted wild birds. I still have a lot to learn. The first few days I allowed the dog to hunt to wide. They were bumping the birds out of range. The last few days tried to get them to hunt closer. I need to learn how to train this. I felt like I was constantly nagging the dog to stay close. Also my dog needs to be more steady, but to be honest there was times when her creeping helped me find the bird.

Overall a great hunt and experince.
I hope youre hooked! Youre right about MT being indescribable. You have to experience it to understand.. Keep after it!
 
Back
Top