I'm pretty cheap when it comes to buying stuff, too. But this year, I finally decided on getting Irish Setters, based on what I've heard from anyone who owns them.
I just ordered a pair of 9 inch Gore Tex Wingshooters from Sportsmans guide - only $100!
I know a lot of people claim problems with their quality, and I had a pair of "Guide Gear" boots that were crap, but when it is a name brand, it is the name brand.
My biggest problem with them is that they are afraid of getting sued by our State, and won't ship anything gun related, ammo, knives, etc. Be thankful all you who live in Free America.