Amateur Hour

beach004

Member
Time, perhaps, for a report from the North Carolina contingent--those without dogs, without a guide, without a put-and-take site. We just showed up and walked: CRP, WPA--and ditches. Lots of ditches: One day I measured 8 miles by mid-afternoon. We were based in the Platte/Kimball area, hunting Nov. 15-18.

Man, if you don't like the weather in SD, wait a day! The first two days the two of us were literally hunting in our shirtsleeves--and the birds were impossible to find, it seemed like; even on SDjim's lovely land, we rarely ran on a bird.

That night, 1.4 inches of rain--unheard of in South Dakota! The next morning, 37 degrees, the perpetual strong north wind, and every minimum maintenance road was slick as owl snot; had to wear a raincoat and hood, adding to the difficulty hearing a bird flush. But now there began to be more birds seen; one field had 25, all but two hens--but at least it was something to see. We gave up on the CRP--with only two people and no dogs, I'm sure the birds cackled silently and let us walk by them, over and over. Instead we focused on ditches. It took some selectivity--many of them had been closely mowed, especially if there appeared to be groomed milo strips in the adjacent field; but that's understandable. We adopted the technique recommended often in this Forum: drop one off, drive a mile, leave car and keys; walker collects the car and leapfrogs; then continue. A nice aspect of the flat country is that even the cheap walkie-talkie radios would reach up to two miles. So we had some success.

The final day was another adventure. Temp in the low 40's, that was nice; but sustained winds 40 mph gusting to 60! Hard to even get the car door open! This was the 8 mile day; and we saw, literally, hundreds of birds; great majority hens, almost all at no-shoot distances, or over land to which we had no access; but it was thrilling to see them, and encouraging for next year to see all those potential mommas. So I reckon, God willing, we'll come back again next year; the weather will always be a crapshoot--the day we left, snow came right behind us and blanketed the area--and I still have no answer to the dog question. But there's a lot more wild pheasants in SD than in NC!

There is already a plethora of portraits of dead poultry on this Forum; I will attach a couple of roadside scenes; they are now my screensavers, reminding me of what beauty can be found, on the backroads of South Dakota.


image_zpsolbt0ixn.jpg

IMG_3264_zpsjmsxungh.jpg
 
Last edited:
You ventured into another part of this great country and had an enjoyable time. Glad it worked out for you. :thumbsup:

The first time to the Dakotas can be exciting just by the weather and you found that to be true - no doubt. ;)
 
Thx fornthe play by play. I Remember my first trip to SD . We only got a few birds between us in 4 days. The 10 hr drive back home all I thought about is that I cant wait to to back. Must like pain punishment and frustration
 
Amateur--clarified

I have left some wrong impressions; that'll teach me to try to write while two grandkids are competing for my attention. First, "amateur" in this case means, "one four-day trip a year"; my daughter, two sons-in-law and I have been coming to South Dakota since 2009, every year. This year two couldn't make it; but being 72, I insisted on not missing the chance.

But we have never been able to figure out the dog thing. We have 'em; for ten years we had a wonderful Golden Retriever who fetched every dove we killed in North Carolina. But how to get said dog to South Dakota? It's 30 hours' driving time from here! Three of us lack the vacation, and one of us the stamina, to drive; we have to fly. So that's why we don't bring, have never brought, a dog.

We DID see one out there; but he wouldn't hunt for us.
Coyote%20crop_zpssadzsgdl.jpg
 
i drive 16 hours each way over 2 days....with 2 dogs in the back, wouldn't bother going without them!
 
With 4-5 drivers that 30 hour drive is just a 6-7 hour driving shifts, with a dog it makes it pretty easy as you stop every 3 hours or so to stretch everyone's legs. We do 15 hours with two guts and two dogs. Just my 2 cents, glad you had a good trip.
 
Enjoyed the report

Beach, thanks for the honest report. I made my third trip to central/NE South Dakota from Florida this year. As far as bird numbers go, this was the worst year to date (6 guys, 4 dogs, 5 days, 24 birds). However, like you, I have enjoyed the trip for other reasons( sunrises, sunsets, open land and crops for miles, old farm steads, fellowship with other hunters, etc). All of the things are different in Florida. We have a 30 hour drive as well, but with 4 guys driving it is manageable. The first year I went I did not have a dog, but other guys did. After hunting behind dogs I could not imagine doing it without them. After the first year I bought a GSP and have had him with me the last 2 years. Our success would be cut down by two-thirds without dogs. The birds that we would have walked past are normally found by a good dog. Not to mention watching them work is half the fun. I hope to return next year, I hope you can as well. Hopefully the bird numbers will increase.
 
Weather jinx

You always bring bad weather with you--DON"T YOU!!! LOL
SDJIM, I sadly have to agree: Two years ago we came in early December: record lows--I think it was -19 degrees one morning, and a foot of snow; last year we came Nov. 15, an unseasonable six-inch snow and -6 degrees; this year same date, and see above. If you plan to hunt SD, check to see when I'm coming, and avoid those dates.
 
We are having some more of that GOOD weather--4 inches on the ground and it's still coming down. I really don't know what to say about this year--it seems that the numbers are down locally --yet hunters with good dogs that work hard at it are doing great. Still it's pheasant hunting and any day you go out your gonna see birds --what more can one ask :thumbsup:
 
Back
Top