Whether it be a bell, check cord, dog bowl or whatever....we all likely have preferences apart from each other.
A bell, a good and treasured bell, can represent more than immediate dog location. It can repesent tradition and past dogs and even can be a memory-primer.
A check cord for training, for me, is different than a check cord on a hunting trip...there, I prefer the flat, synthetic over the standard stiff cord because it absorbs no moisture or grit and remains pliable in the cold. For some that would make no never mind tho.
I far and away prefer a rubber dog bowl over stainless on a hunting trip...much quieter and a dog can even lay on them in a crate to a degree....but the quiet is the big appeal.
Point being...product sales are never truely satisfied by a generalized catagory item.
Your best step would be to run a pointing dog in your rotation to tune into the niches hunters love to fill.
Re the so-termed "tracking collars".
As has been discussed ad nauseum, especially Astros, the positives they deliver far surpass "tracking"....and the negatives are primarily in the mind of those who do not run them, for one reason or tother.
Combo collars are popular now.....kinda appeals to that element of human nature where multi-use seems a good thing. I prefer a seperate collar for a Garmin or an e-collar or a beeper......multi-use equipment is pretty rugged but...nice to keep the eggs rolling around more than one basket.
I will say that the e-collars with a locater appear a good deal but as I almost never run an e-collar on my 3 setters, I will likely never find out if the Internet plusses trumpeted regarding them really exist.
Thornton
AnyOldDog